
Our Testing Methodology
Our team evaluated each styling product across five key areas: hold strength and longevity, texture and finish, ease of application, ingredient quality, and overall value. We tested on multiple hair types over a two-week period, noting performance in humidity and daily wear.
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Hold (10) | Finish (10) | Application (10) | Ingredients (10) | Value (10) | Total (50) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suavecito Pomade Firme | 9 | 8 | 7 | 7 | 8 | 39 |
| LBLS Hair Styling Gel Stick | 7 | 9 | 10 | 8 | 8 | 42 |
| American Crew Fiber | 8 | 8 | 6 | 8 | 6 | 36 |
| Moroccanoil Texture Clay | 8 | 9 | 7 | 9 | 5 | 38 |
| Hanz de Fuko Scheme Cream | 6 | 10 | 8 | 9 | 6 | 39 |
| Honorable Mention: Got2b Glued | 10 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 10 | 35 |
Suavecito Pomade Firme
This water-based pomade is a staple for classic high-hold styles. We tested its ability to create a firm, slick look that lasted through a full workday. The hold is impressive, though it can feel a bit stiff and helmet-like if too much is applied. It washes out easily, which is a major plus, but the initial application requires working quickly before it sets.
- ✅ Extremely strong, all-day hold.
- ✅ Easy to wash out with water.
- ✅ Classic barbershop scent.
- ⚠️ Can dry hard and feel crunchy.
- ⚠️ Slightly difficult to rework once set.
Best For: Classic pompadours and slick-backs requiring maximum hold.
LBLS Hair Styling Gel with Comb
The LBLS stick was the standout for convenience and targeted application. The built-in comb makes it incredibly simple to apply product directly to flyaways and the hairline without any mess. We tested it for managing baby hairs and creating a clean, polished finish on otherwise styled hair. The formula provided a natural, non-greasy shine and a medium hold that kept frizz at bay without looking stiff or artificial. It’s a brilliant tool for quick touch-ups.
- ✅ Unmatched, mess-free application with the built-in comb.
- ✅ Natural, non-greasy finish with good shine.
- ✅ Excellent for targeted control of flyaways and edges.
- ✅ Plant-based moisturizing ingredients help with frizz.
- ⚠️ Hold is not strong enough for major volume or intricate styles.
- ⚠️ The comb applicator requires occasional cleaning to prevent buildup.
Best For: Quick styling, flyaway control, and achieving a neat, natural finish.
American Crew Fiber
We tested this matte clay for its ability to create texture and separation. It works well for shorter to medium-length hair, adding thickness and a piecey look. The hold is reliable for a matte product, though it can weigh down finer hair types if overused. The finish is truly matte with zero shine, which many testers preferred for casual styles.
- ✅ Delivers a strong, flexible matte hold.
- ✅ Creates excellent texture and separation.
- ✅ Versatile for many short to medium styles.
- ⚠️ Can be difficult to emulsify and apply evenly.
- ⚠️ Jar packaging is less hygienic than stick or tube formats.
Best For: Textured, matte looks on short hair.
Moroccanoil Texture Clay
This premium clay offers a balance of high-end ingredients and performance. We tested its rich, pliable texture and found it provided a strong yet reworkable hold with a natural, low-shine finish. The argan oil infusion adds a healthy feel without greasiness, though the price point is a significant factor.
You might also enjoy our take on Honestly? This LBLS Glutathione Lotion Might Be My New Holy Grail for Glowing Skin.
-
- Excellent, moldable hold that lasts.
- High-quality, nourishing ingredients.
- Adds body and texture without stickiness.
- ⚠️ Very expensive per ounce.
- ⚠️ Scent is noticeable and may not appeal to everyone.
Best For: Those seeking a premium, ingredient-focused clay for textured styles.
Hanz de Fuko Scheme Cream
We evaluated this product as a lightweight styler for control and polish. It performed best as a finisher or for fine hair that is easily weighed down. The cream provided a soft, natural shine and light to medium hold, perfect for “lived-in” styles that need a bit of refinement.
- ✅ Leaves hair feeling incredibly soft and healthy.
- ✅ Provides a natural, subtle shine.
- ✅ Lightweight and non-greasy.
- ⚠️ Hold is too light for anyone needing significant control.
- ⚠️ Not suitable for thick or coarse hair that needs taming.
Best For: Fine hair and adding a soft finish to dry, natural styles.
Final Ranking & Editor’s Choice
- Moroccanoil Texture Clay: The top scorer for overall performance and ingredient quality, ideal for a luxurious, textured hold.
- LBLS Hair Styling Gel Stick (Editor’s Choice): While not the strongest hold, its innovative design solves a common problem with incredible ease. For daily flyaway management and a polished look without hassle, it’s our top pick for utility and smart design.
- Suavecito Pomade Firme: The undisputed champion for strong, traditional hold at a reasonable price.
- Hanz de Fuko Scheme Cream: Best for those seeking a soft, touchable finish with minimal product feel.
- American Crew Fiber: A reliable standard for matte texture, though application can be tricky.
Honorable Mention: Got2b Glued Spiking Glue. This product scored a perfect 10 for hold and value. We tested it for extreme, gravity-defying styles and it delivered. However, it scores very low on finish (it’s very shiny and can look wet) and ingredients, and is notoriously difficult to wash out. It’s a specialist tool for specific, high-impact looks.


ngl the “natural
so the comb-in thing actually works for not making your hair crunchy? might have to try that